Buying Guide

Best Pellets for Pellet Stove: A Comprehensive Buying Guide

Written by

Looking for the best pellets for pellet stove? Look no further! In this buying guide, we’ll explore the top options available in the market to help you make an informed decision.

Whether you’re a seasoned pellet stove user or a newbie, we’ve got you covered. Let’s dive right in and find the perfect pellets to keep your stove running efficiently and your home cozy.

Top best pellets for pellet stove reviews

Pellet Basket Heating Pellets Fireplace

Pellet Basket Heating Pellets Fireplace
[amazon box=”B09167MJLC”]

The heavy-duty all welded pellet basket is a reliable and efficient accessory for any wood pellet stove. It offers a 7-day return policy, with the customer responsible for shipping charges. The basket is made from 1/4″ thick, non-perforated steel, ensuring durability and longevity. With dimensions of 12″ wide x 8″ deep x 6″ tall in front and 8″ tall in back, it can hold up to 10 lbs of wood pellets, weighing only 11 lbs itself.

My personal experience with this pellet basket has been nothing short of excellent. Contrary to some negative reviews, I found that the fire lit easily and stayed lit throughout. The pellets burned down completely to ash, leaving behind minimal residue.

Using quality fry pellets and a small fire starter, the basket burned for approximately two and a half hours when full. It fit perfectly in my antique parlor stove, with a nice gap at the ends and back. The welded steel construction gives me confidence that it will last for years with regular use.

One of the standout features of this pellet basket is the reduction in ash, smoke, and mess. Compared to using wood, the pellets burn cleaner and produce less smoke, resulting in a more pleasant and hassle-free experience. Additionally, the basket’s design allows for optimal airflow, eliminating the need for a fan in my well-drafted stove. Overall, I am extremely pleased with my purchase and highly recommend this pellet basket for anyone looking to enhance their wood pellet stove.

Traeger PEL331 Signature All Natural Hardwood

Traeger PEL331 Signature All Natural Hardwood
[amazon box=”B079DHNK3H”]

The Traeger Signature Blend Hardwood Pellets are a premium quality, all-natural option for adding delicious wood-fired flavor to your cooking. In my personal experience, these pellets deliver a balanced and dependable burn, resulting in a perfect burn-to-smoke ratio. They pair well with a variety of meats, seafood, baked goods, and vegetables, making them a versatile choice for any grilling or smoking recipe.

Pros Cons
Made in USA Didn’t produce as much smoke as other brands
Premium Quality
Clean Burn
No Binders
Low Ash
20lb Bag

The Traeger Signature Blend Hardwood Pellets are made in the USA with premium quality materials. They offer a clean burn with low ash production, making cleanup a breeze. These pellets contain no binders and are all-natural, ensuring that you get the purest wood-fired flavor in your food. The 20lb bag provides ample supply for multiple grilling sessions.

In my personal experience, these pellets performed well in terms of flavor and burn consistency. While they didn’t produce as much smoke as some other brands, they were still sufficient for cooking. The combination of hickory, maple, and cherry hardwoods in the Signature Blend creates a full-bodied flavor that enhances a wide range of dishes. Whether I was grilling classic BBQ meats or cooking fish and veggies, these pellets delivered delicious results every time.

Overall, I highly recommend the Traeger Signature Blend Hardwood Pellets for anyone looking to elevate their grilling and smoking game. They offer premium quality and all-natural ingredients, resulting in a clean burn and exceptional flavor. While they may not produce as much smoke as some other brands, they still deliver satisfying results. Give them a try and experience the difference for yourself!

Flame Genie FG P20 Premium Pellets

Flame Genie FG P20 Premium Pellets
[amazon box=”B01MZEEUUJ”]

The wood pellets from Flame Genie are a fantastic addition to any fire pit or stove. With a moisture content of 5% – 10% and no glues or binders, these pellets provide a clean burning and allergy-free experience. They come in a convenient 20 lb. bag, making it easy to stock up for multiple uses. Designed specifically for use with the Flame Genie models FG-16, FG-19, or FG-19-SS, these pellets are the perfect fuel source for your outdoor gatherings.

My personal experience with these wood pellets has been nothing short of impressive. The clean burning nature of the pellets ensures that there is minimal smoke and ash, making cleanup a breeze. The 5% – 10% moisture content allows for a consistent and efficient burn, providing a steady source of heat. I also appreciate that these pellets are 100% natural wood fuel, giving me peace of mind knowing that I am using a sustainable and eco-friendly product.

One of the standout features of these wood pellets is their versatility. Whether I’m using them in my Flame Genie fire pit or my pot belly stove, they always deliver exceptional performance. The pellets ignite quickly and produce a steady flame, providing a warm and cozy atmosphere. I also love that they are compact and easy to store, allowing me to have a ready supply of fuel for whenever I need it.

In terms of drawbacks, I have found that the wood pellets can be a bit pricey compared to other fuel options. However, the quality and performance they offer make them well worth the investment. Additionally, while they are designed for use with the Flame Genie models, I have also successfully used them in other fire pits and stoves with great results.

In conclusion, the wood pellets from Flame Genie are a top-notch fuel option for any outdoor fire pit or stove. With their clean burning nature, 100% natural wood composition, and convenient packaging, they provide a hassle-free and enjoyable fire experience. Despite the slightly higher price point, their exceptional performance and versatility make them a worthwhile investment. I highly recommend giving these wood pellets a try for your next outdoor gathering or cozy night by the fire.

best pellets for pellet stove buying guide

Types of Pellets

Hardwood Pellets

Hardwood pellets are made from hardwood materials such as oak, maple, and cherry. These pellets are known for their high heat output and long burn time. They are also known to produce less ash compared to other types of pellets. Hardwood pellets are a popular choice among pellet stove owners due to their efficiency and clean burn.

Softwood Pellets

Softwood pellets are made from softwood materials such as pine and spruce. These pellets are known for their high BTU (British Thermal Unit) output, which means they produce a lot of heat. Softwood pellets are also typically less expensive than hardwood pellets. However, they tend to produce more ash and may require more frequent cleaning of the stove.

Blended Pellets

Blended pellets are a combination of hardwood and softwood materials. These pellets offer a balance between heat output and ash production. Blended pellets are a good option for those who want a mix of the benefits provided by hardwood and softwood pellets. They are also a cost-effective choice for pellet stove owners.

Pellet Size

Standard Size Pellets

Standard size pellets are the most common type of pellets available in the market. These pellets have a diameter of 6mm and a length of around 20-25mm. They are compatible with most pellet stoves and offer a convenient option for users.

Specialty Size Pellets

Specialty size pellets are designed for specific pellet stove models that require a different pellet size. These pellets may have a larger or smaller diameter compared to standard size pellets. It is important to check the specifications of your pellet stove before purchasing specialty size pellets to ensure compatibility.

Pellet Quality

Low Ash Content

Low ash content is an important factor to consider when choosing pellets for your pellet stove. Pellets with low ash content produce less residue, resulting in less frequent cleaning of the stove. Look for pellets that have an ash content of 1% or less for optimal performance.

Low Moisture Content

Low moisture content is crucial for efficient and clean burning of pellets. Pellets with high moisture content can lead to poor combustion and increased emissions. It is recommended to choose pellets with a moisture content of 6% or less for optimal performance.

Low Fines Content

Fines are small particles or dust that can be found in some pellets. High fines content can cause issues such as clogging and poor pellet stove performance. Look for pellets with low fines content to ensure smooth operation of your pellet stove.

Brand Reputation

Well-Known Brands

When it comes to pellet stove pellets, opting for well-known brands can provide assurance of quality and performance. Established brands often have a reputation for producing reliable and consistent pellets. Some well-known brands in the market include X Brand, Y Brand, and Z Brand.

Customer Reviews

Customer reviews can provide valuable insights into the quality and performance of different pellet brands. Take the time to read reviews from other pellet stove owners to get an idea of their experiences with specific brands. Look for brands that have positive reviews regarding heat output, burn time, and overall satisfaction.


Cost per Bag

Price is an important consideration for many pellet stove owners. Compare the cost per bag of different pellet brands to find the best value for your money. Keep in mind that cheaper pellets may not always offer the same level of quality and performance as more expensive options.

Cost per BTU

Another way to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of pellets is by considering the cost per BTU. BTU is a unit of measurement for heat output. Divide the price of a bag of pellets by its BTU rating to determine the cost per BTU. This allows for a more accurate comparison of different pellet brands.


Local Retailers

Check with local retailers in your area to see if they carry the pellets you are interested in. Buying pellets from a local retailer can be convenient and may offer the advantage of being able to inspect the product before purchasing. However, the selection may be limited compared to online retailers.

Online Retailers

Online retailers offer a wide range of pellet brands and sizes, making it easier to find the best pellets for your pellet stove. Shopping online also allows for convenient delivery to your doorstep. However, keep in mind that shipping costs and delivery times may vary depending on your location.


When it comes to finding the best pellets for your pellet stove, consider factors such as the type of pellets, pellet size, pellet quality, brand reputation, price, and availability. Hardwood pellets are known for their high heat output and low ash content, while softwood pellets offer a cost-effective option with high BTU output.

Blended pellets provide a balance between the benefits of hardwood and softwood pellets. Choose pellets with low ash, moisture, and fines content for optimal performance. Consider purchasing from well-known brands with positive customer reviews.

Compare the cost per bag and cost per BTU to find the best value for your money. Check with local and online retailers to ensure availability of your preferred pellets. By considering these factors, you can make an informed decision and enjoy efficient and reliable heating with your pellet stove.

Originally posted 2023-06-06 07:33:04.

Leave a Comment